Final Thursday, HP CEO Enrique Lores addressed the corporate’s controversial follow of bricking printers when customers load them with third-party ink. Chatting with CNBC Tv, he mentioned, “We’ve seen which you could embed viruses within the cartridges. By means of the cartridge, [the virus can] go to the printer, [and then] from the printer, go to the community.”
That scary situation may assist clarify why HP, which was hit this month with one other lawsuit over its Dynamic Safety system, insists on deploying it to printers.
To analyze, I turned to Ars Technica senior safety editor Dan Goodin. He informed me that he did not know of any assaults actively used within the wild which can be able to utilizing a cartridge to contaminate a printer.
Goodin additionally put the query to Mastodon, and cybersecurity professionals, many with experience in embedded-device hacking, have been decidedly skeptical.
HP’s Proof
Unsurprisingly, Lores’ declare comes from HP-backed analysis. The corporate’s bug bounty program tasked researchers from Bugcrowd with figuring out if it is doable to make use of an ink cartridge as a cyberthreat. HP argued that ink cartridge microcontroller chips, that are used to speak with the printer, could possibly be an entryway for assaults.
As detailed in a 2022 article from analysis agency Actionable Intelligence, a researcher in this system discovered a option to hack a printer through a third-party ink cartridge. The researcher was reportedly unable to carry out the identical hack with an HP cartridge.
Shivaun Albright, HP’s chief technologist of print safety, mentioned on the time:
Albright added that the malware “remained on the printer in reminiscence” after the cartridge was eliminated.
HP acknowledges that there is no proof of such a hack occurring within the wild. Nonetheless, as a result of chips utilized in third-party ink cartridges are reprogrammable (their “code may be modified through a resetting device proper within the area,” in response to Actionable Intelligence), they’re much less safe, the corporate says. The chips are mentioned to be programmable in order that they’ll nonetheless work in printers after firmware updates.
HP additionally questions the safety of third-party ink firms’ provide chains, particularly in comparison with its personal provide chain safety, which is ISO/IEC-certified.
So HP did discover a theoretical method for cartridges to be hacked, and it is affordable for the corporate to situation a bug bounty to establish such a danger. However its answer for this risk was introduced earlier than it confirmed there could possibly be a risk. HP added ink cartridge safety coaching to its bug bounty program in 2020, and the above analysis was launched in 2022. HP began utilizing Dynamic Safety in 2016, ostensibly to resolve the issue that it sought to show exists years later.
