I in contrast the perfect headphones from Apple, Sony, Bose, and Sonos: Here is how the AirPods Max wins

Previously few years, Bose, Sony, Sonos, and Beats have launched premium headphones to compete with one another and Apple’s AirPods Max. 

I’ve worn the entire AirPods Max’s high rivals, they usually every excel in numerous classes. However for an older canine on this battle, the AirPods Max are nonetheless kicking. Since their 2020 launch (and 2024 re-release), the Max have not acquired many important software program or {hardware} updates, apart from new colours, a USB-C port, and help for lossless audio through USB-C.

Additionally: The 12 greatest headphones of 2025

So, 5 years later, set on the backdrop of a possible successor this fall, are the AirPods Max nonetheless value shopping for? After testing the perfect headphones available on the market, here is my shopping for recommendation.

The great: design, gadget interoperability, and nice sound

One factor is indeniable: the AirPods Max are a phenomenal pair of headphones. They’re easy, glossy, and infrequently imitated — but by no means replicated. The stainless-steel accents give it an elevated look, no logos or branding make them seem subtle, and the Digital Crown efficiently replaces a number of buttons that may be confused with each other.

Additionally: Here is how a free software program improve made the Sonos Ace value their price ticket

Within the design class, the Sonos Ace are the Max’s closest rival. They’re additionally outlined by clear traces, a easy design, metallic accents, and detachable magnetic ear pads, however have thinner earcups and a lighter construct. The Ace characteristic their very own tackle the Digital Crown with a equally functioning Content material Key, however positioned in an easier-to-reach spot on the ear cup.

Bose’s QuietComfort Extremely sport aluminum yokes for enhanced sturdiness, however many of the headphone is made from plastic. Equally, Sony’s XM6 is constructed with largely plastic — albeit with supplies which might be extremely sustainable. 

For Apple customers, the AirPods Max are the definitive over-ear headphones possibility, due to their computerized pairing together with your iPhone, iPad, Mac, or Apple TV. Whilst they close to their fifth birthday, the AirPods Max nonetheless sound unimaginable by in the present day’s customary. Apple’s Personalised Spatial Audio works superbly, making a wider soundstage that does not sound too computerized.

Additionally: Why these headphones are nonetheless the perfect from Bose – though they are a yr previous

Within the spatial audio division, the Sonos Ace and Beats Studio Professional are fierce rivals, offering an analogous spatial listening expertise. 

The AirPods Max have nice noise-canceling skills, owing to their efficiency with eight microphones for energetic noise cancellation (ANC). The Sonos Ace carry out simply in addition to the Max in canceling environmental noise, however Bose’s QuietComfort Extremely and Sony’s WH-1000XM6 are the kings of ANC. 

Nonetheless, even 5 years later, the AirPods Max nonetheless have a leg up on all of their rivals’ Transparency Modes. Apple’s Transparency Mode is the clearest, most clear, and most natural-sounding. 

The mesh ear pads of the Apple headphones, whereas totally different from these of different manufacturers, have additionally held up effectively. They’re agency with out being exhausting, offering a good but snug seal round your ears for immersion. The shortage of polyurethane leather-based on the ear pads concurrently provides to their expense and person expertise.

Additionally: I changed my Bose UltraComfort headphones for the Sony XM6 – here is the way it went

My colleague, Kerry Wan, ZDNET’s managing editor, says the Max’s mesh ear pads are top-of-the-line issues about them. “I’ve discovered the AirPods Max’s mesh-style ear cushions to alleviate strain and sweat build-up higher than the waxy, silicone-based covers discovered on competing headphones,” he says.

And I’ve to agree; the mesh pads really feel higher in opposition to my pores and skin and handle warmth buildup higher. However with nice energy comes nice duty. The mesh pads take in sweat, oils, and odors as an alternative of preserving them on the floor just like the rivals’ ear pads. Thus, you’ll be able to both throw them within the wash each occasionally or spend the cash to exchange them.

The unhealthy: Software program, all issues battery life, and an ode to consolation

I nonetheless respect Apple’s H1 audio processor, nevertheless it’s clear that it could’t sustain with the {industry}’s extra superior software program options. That is why AirPods Max customers look longingly out the window when AirPods Professional 2 customers get the entire cool software program updates each September.

As of late, adaptive noise cancellation is all the fashion. Headphone processors are clever sufficient to take heed to your atmosphere’s noise ranges and make use of the suitable quantity of noise cancellation. This characteristic can protect battery life, assist with situational consciousness, and usually be extra handy than manually switching ANC modes.

Additionally: Sony WH-1000XM6 vs. Bose QuietComfort Extremely: How to decide on the perfect noise-canceling headphone

I usually rag on the Bose QuietComfort Extremely’s brief 24-hour battery life, however Apple’s is shorter at 20 hours. The AirPods Max have poor endurance in comparison with their rivals, with the Sonos Ace and Sony XM6 testing for round 30 hours with ANC on. 

My recommendation is that you simply should not purchase the AirPods Max if you do not have not less than one Apple product, and I usually attribute that to paying for options you’ll be able to’t use, like Discover My and Personalised Spatial Audio.

Moreover, with no companion app, software program updates are wrapped into iOS updates, making it not possible to replace your AirPods with out an iPhone, iPad, or Mac. ZDNET’s Kerry Wan is especially an Android person, although he shamelessly admits to preserving an iPhone round to replace the headphones and check the most recent options. That is clearly not the case for many customers.

Additionally: 5 iOS 26 options I already cannot stay with out – and entry them

One other unsurprising caveat is that the AirPods Max are a hefty pair of headphones. They’re heavier than all of their challengers, and their skinny mesh headband would not act as sufficient of a counterweight for the heavy earcups once I put on them for lengthy durations. The Sonos Ace and Bose QuietComfort Extremely have plushy earcups and sturdier headbands, they usually’re higher fitted to long-term put on once I journey or work at my desk.

ZDNET’s shopping for recommendation

Because the AirPods Max put together to rejoice their fifth anniversary, it is spectacular that they are nonetheless within the premium headphone dialog; that is a testomony to their efficiency and future proofing. I’ve extra good than unhealthy issues to say about them, however I do not assume they’re for everybody, not even for each Apple fan.

For those who by no means stray from the iOS ecosystem and prioritize design, nice sound, and good noise cancellation, the AirPods Max will serve you effectively. Simply you should definitely purchase them on sale; it occurs usually.

For those who worth an AirPods Max-inspired design, consolation, sound, and full compatibility with iOS and Android, take into account the Sonos Ace. If consolation and noise cancellation are on the high of your record, attempt the Bose QC Extremely. If impeccable sound, industry-leading noise cancellation are your must-haves, go along with the Sony XM6. 

And in order for you headphones with a easy, clear design that provides features of Apple’s person interface and helps native Android options, the Beats Studio Professional are for you.