When Canadians say they don’t need to be a part of America, they actually imply it. And so they know what they’re speaking about. Canada, the place I used to be born and raised, has at all times had a peculiarly intimate data of the US, and never solely as a result of many Canadians spent winter breaks within the again seat headed south on I-95.
But when Canadians are always conscious of their southern neighbor, the reverse is not true. I’ve lived in New York Metropolis for greater than half my life, and I’ve realized that Individuals usually seek advice from Canada solely when it’s an election yr and so they’re threatening to maneuver there. I way back acknowledged they weren’t really speaking in regards to the nation Canada, however moderately the concept of Canada, which appears to drift within the American creativeness as a obscure Xanadu full of well mannered folks, simply accessible well being care and a relative absence of weapons.
This has modified, and never in a great way. Since Donald Trump returned to the White Home, he’s repeatedly threatened to pummel Canada with crushing tariffs and upend century-old border agreements. He appears decided to annex a sovereign nation, with a inhabitants of 40 million folks, and delights in referring to it because the 51st state.
This has been, to place it mildly, unwelcome information to some 90 p.c of Canadians, who don’t need to trade their citizenship for a U.S. passport, in accordance with a January Angus Reid ballot. Certainly, Canada is experiencing an uncommon surge in nationalism in response to Mr. Trump’s bloviating. The Boycott America motion is going robust, and Justin Trudeau’s Liberal Social gathering, now led by newly sworn in Prime Minister Mark Carney, has skilled a breathtaking turnaround within the polls.
What appears to get misplaced in a lot of the latest information protection is that a big a part of the Canadian identification — frustratingly so, at instances — has lengthy been primarily based on not being American. (When the Canadian children in my life are in search of a approach to mock me, they inform me I’m performing like an American. That I’ve almost misplaced the power to inform the temperature in Celsius doesn’t assist my case.)
As Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau — Justin’s father — informed Richard Nixon in 1969, “Dwelling subsequent to you is in some methods like sleeping with an elephant,” including, “one is affected by each twitch and grunt.”
The elephant was in every single place. Earlier than my compatriots started booing it, Canadians routinely sang the American nationwide anthem at hockey video games alongside our personal. After I was rising up, the American stations on our 12-channel tv dial had been interspersed with Canadian ones. We may thus get the flashy American protection of any occasion, which nearly solely centered on how information or sports activities affected Individuals, after which flip to the extra sober Canadian tackle the identical, which informed you every part else. (ABC Information was a double win as a result of Peter Jennings was Canadian American.)
This consciousness even trickled all the way down to my Converse and Spell toy — I might usually must resolve between an ideal rating or the proper spelling of phrases like honour and color.
Within the early Nineteen Nineties Canada determined the nation wanted one other manner to consider itself and began the Canadian Heritage Minute: 60-second, extremely produced public service bulletins that recalled necessary moments in Canadian historical past. Throughout industrial breaks from, say, “The Younger and the Stressed,” one would find out how Canada did nice issues — possibly, secretly, all the nice issues, regardless of what American textbooks or Hollywood would possibly recommend. (Superman was co-created by a Canadian-born comedian e book artist; basketball was created by a Canadian; and on D-Day Canadian forces pushed farther inland than these from both America or Britain.)
The aim was to assist Canadians know our distinct identification in addition to we knew our neighbors’.
Till not too long ago, the concept of America annexing Canada was a state of affairs that belonged in a “Blame Canada” “South Park” episode. America declaring battle on Canada was, actually, the plot of the 1995 comedy “Canadian Bacon,” starring John Sweet, a Canadian, about an American president who lifts his scores by turning Canada into an enemy.
There’s a protracted historical past of uncomfortably oblivious therapy from our American “cousins.” In latest weeks, I’ve been reminded of the 1992 World Collection wherein the Toronto Blue Jays confronted the Atlanta Braves. The primary video games had been held in Atlanta, and in the course of the Canadian nationwide anthem the U.S. Marine Corps shade guard marched onto the sphere with the Canadian flag the wrong way up. President George H.W. Bush needed to formally apologize to Canada for the obvious accident.
It was much less humorous when President George W. Bush forgot to incorporate Canada in his 2001 speech to Congress following the Sept. 11 assaults, thanking the nations of the world for his or her help. (He remembered Iran and El Salvador.) This, after Canada took in some 33,000 stranded American vacationers, together with 7,000 in Gander, Newfoundland, inhabitants 9,650, the place they had been cared for and fed by locals. “Come From Away,” the Tony Award-winning musical, was born of that have.
Ignored although it is likely to be, Canada, relaxation assured, is an actual place — one with loads of its personal issues and a deep understanding of its neighbour. It’s been downright infuriating to see some Individuals considering how Canada turning into the 51st state is likely to be an excellent factor … for American Democrats. As Canada’s minister of overseas affairs, Mélanie Joly, not too long ago mentioned, “If there’s a rustic on earth that understands the Individuals, it’s us.” In different phrases: Canadians have been to America; they don’t seem to be transferring in.
Glynnis MacNicol is the creator of the memoir “I’m Largely Right here to Take pleasure in Myself,” host of the podcast “Wilder: A Reckoning With Laura Ingalls Wilder” and creator of the e-newsletter Good Choices.
The Occasions is dedicated to publishing a variety of letters to the editor. We’d like to listen to what you concentrate on this or any of our articles. Listed here are some suggestions. And right here’s our e-mail: letters@nytimes.com.
Observe the New York Occasions Opinion part on Fb, Instagram, TikTok, Bluesky, WhatsApp and Threads.
