Opinion | Michelle Goldberg Imagines a Second Trump Inauguration

This transcript was created utilizing speech recognition software program. Whereas it has been reviewed by human transcribers, it could comprise errors. Please overview the episode audio earlier than quoting from this transcript

and e-mail transcripts@nytimes.com with any questions. suppose we’re a superb group.

I’m Patrick Healy, deputy editor for the Occasions Opinion part. And we’re standing at a caucus web site on the Van Meter Faculty in Western Des Moines. Voting has simply concluded in Monday night time’s Iowa caucuses. Individuals lined as much as put their ballots in these brown paper baggage that you just’d get at a grocery retailer, and the counting goes to start quickly.

We all know that Donald Trump has already been declared the winner of the Iowa caucuses. It’s type of a humorous factor as a result of individuals are nonetheless counting the votes, despite the fact that the consequence has been declared.

We’re going to move again now to the lodge. It’s freezing out, so we’re placing on the mittens and the hat and speaking to my colleague Michelle Goldberg, who’s been following the race. And I wish to hear what she has to make of the outcomes.

Hey, Michelle. How are you?

I’m good. How are — I imply, I assume pretty much as good as anybody might be. How are you?

I’m good. I’m again from the chilly, from an Iowa caucus web site, and I’m completely satisfied to be speaking to you. So we’re speaking at about 9:17 p.m. Iowa time, the caucuses began right here a pair hours in the past, and simply 31 minutes after the caucuses started, the Related Press known as it for Trump. Proper now, it’s trying like Florida Governor Ron DeSantis goes to return in second. And I wished to ask you, simply first off, are you stunned that Trump gained so simply and appears to have such a robust margin?

I imply, no, that is probably the most predictable factor possible. That is — I imply, it’s simply — I can’t consider one other information story I’ve coated that’s directly so momentously horrible and boringly anticlimactic.

It’s so true. I imply, it’s slightly unusual, Michelle. You and I each coated elections, and when the talk is whether or not it’s going to be a 30-point blowout versus a 25-point blowout, it’s slightly surreal within the anticlimactic sense.

I imply, it jogs my memory simply of the debates, truly, as a result of the debates have been additionally this type of Potemkin model of a traditional main as a result of they by no means mattered as a result of the entrance runner was by no means a part of them. So individuals would analyze whether or not Nikki Haley or Ron DeSantis got here out on high, and it was all simply fully irrelevant as a result of that is Donald Trump’s get together.

I imply, that is going to be the third consecutive election through which Republicans, barring some spectacular flip of occasions, nominate Donald Trump. I imply, in 2016, there was this sense of, oh my god, is he truly saying that? And what’s going to occur? And the way is it that he’s saying this stuff and his assist simply retains constructing whereas all people is numb. They’re inured. No one thinks that something that he says goes to be too far. And so it’s simply all actually, actually boring.

And but the stakes are so excessive, as you’ve written about.

Effectively, and that’s what I believe is so upsetting. And I believe lots of people are utilizing the identical language. Persons are saying it appears like we’re sleepwalking off a cliff. There’s this sense that, on the one hand, there’s little or no vitality or momentum amongst anti-Trump forces. The left is sort of despairing and divided and exhausted. And but that is an election that I believe goes to find out whether or not now we have different elections.

And what’s so upsetting is that individuals are already so weary and exhausted. Once you discuss to individuals exterior of politics — perhaps you’ve had this expertise too — they are saying, oh, I’m simply pretending it’s not taking place. I’ve to dam it out for my very own psychological well being. And that is going to go on now. I imply, the final election, for all intents and functions, has began. And there’s sufficient time between now and the final election to conceive and provides delivery to a toddler. It is a lengthy, very long time that we’re going to be residing with this each excessive low vitality however extraordinarily existential combat.

It’s actually attention-grabbing, the notion of sleepwalking into one thing as a result of simply tonight, one Trump voter on the caucus web site that I used to be at, who was a really nice lady sort of making the case for Trump in a really sort of low-key method —

— then, out of the blue veered into saying they should go.

Final query — how do you’re feeling about 4 extra years with Biden?

You simply have these sort of stunning statements that do remind you that this isn’t one thing that anybody in American can sleepwalk by that, actually, some components of the MAGA base are enjoying for stakes.

To me, the attention-grabbing query is whether or not it may have been totally different if Republicans had acted totally different as an alternative of doing what they at all times do and sitting again and hoping that anyone else takes care of their Trump drawback, not less than the a part of the Republican Celebration and Republican elites that don’t wish to see one other Trump presidency.

So I used to be polls from a 12 months in the past. A 12 months in the past, most Republicans wished to maneuver on, I believe not essentially as a result of they have been disenchanted with Trumpism, however as a result of they only seen the function that Trump performed within the 2022 election, which went very dangerous for them. And they also have been type of like, this man is a loser. We have to get previous him.

And so what occurred in between then and now? I imply, a part of it, clearly, is the indictments and — I don’t know that it was preordained that he would come out of that with most Republican voters believing that he was a martyr, however I believe to ensure that it to have been totally different, you’ll have needed to see some sort of coordinated motion by leaders of the get together to sign that, no, he misplaced the election.

No, these indictments, particularly those for paperwork and for January 6, these are actually severe. As a substitute, all through this election, you’ve seen the opposite candidates not desirous to take Trump on instantly, sort of reasoning that the bottom already likes him, and in order that’s a loser — which can be true, however then why are you operating? So I’m curious, do you suppose issues may have been totally different?

I believe talking to voters in Iowa the previous couple of days, that sense of the Trump was inevitable all alongside that except he did one thing that was an actual self-inflicted wound, he would in any other case be the nominee.

Speaking to loads of these voters about his authorized issues, and a few of them introduced it up himself, the notion that he’s, as soon as once more, the sufferer of a witch hunt, that he’s as soon as once more the sufferer of a rigged system, despite the fact that that’s not factually true by any means, it’s an article of religion inside the get together.

What’s the message that you really want Individuals to take from the outcomes tonight? What would you like people who find themselves watching Iowa to return away actually understanding or excited about?

I believe the primary is simply that is taking place. I’ve seen some polls that recommend that almost all voters who aren’t tremendous plugged in sort of nonetheless don’t imagine that Trump goes to be the nominee, or not less than some evaluation suggesting that. And so that is taking place. I do know individuals are exhausted. They’re demobilized. However in case you don’t need a far worse rerun of 2016 to 2020, in case you don’t need mass deportations and a totally politicized Justice Division and extra judges on the Supreme Court docket just like the three that Donald Trump already positioned there and all these various things, individuals are going to wish to re-engage even when they really feel lukewarm about Joe Biden.

It nonetheless shocks me when individuals say there’s actually nothing a lot at stake about this election. Each American voter needs to be ready to decide, I believe, in regards to the very sturdy probability that Donald Trump would be the Republican nominee in November of 2024 and what the results of re-electing him can be. You’ve been calling on voters to remain outraged and sharp and on level about Trump to keep away from what you’ve known as “discovered helplessness.” I really like that line. I believe that basically speaks for lots of parents proper now. What’s a giant win for Trump tonight, which is what we’re , say, to you about that sort of discovered helplessness urgency?

Effectively, I believe that it’s already set in. I believe it’s already perhaps irreversible within the Republican Celebration. However despite the fact that Democrats are unpopular, despite the fact that Biden is unpopular, the issues that the Republican Celebration stands for are unpopular, and so what actually scares me is, once more, that I believe individuals have blocked out how dangerous it was.

There’s individuals who say, nicely, I did positive throughout the Trump years, who give him credit score for all of the sort of good financial traits that have been occurring on the planet, after which sort of absolve him for every thing that occurred within the final 12 months of his presidency, however I additionally suppose that individuals simply neglect how scary it typically was to have somebody so uncontrolled in cost. And it’s very tough to not let your self get acculturated. He has modified the tradition. He has shifted our conception of what’s regular in a method that we’d by no means get again the sort of innocence that many people loved in 2015 and 2016.

However, on the identical time, I simply suppose that — think about what it is going to be prefer to see Donald Trump inaugurated once more. Think about simply the utter bleakness. And also you gained’t even have the sense, I don’t suppose, of the cavalry displaying up with the Girls’s March as a result of the primary time Trump was elected, it was a shock, and it set off this large counter-reaction, and folks have been mobilized, whereas this time, I strongly suspect that individuals gained’t be capable to say this isn’t who we’re. It is going to manifestly be who we’re. And I believe individuals will simply flip inward and attempt to shut it out as a lot as attainable, and that can contribute to letting him do his worst.

Michelle, I actually missed you in Iowa, however I’m actually glad that I bought to have the possibility to speak to you first tonight as these votes are coming in. It’s such a pleasure.

Oh, nicely, thanks a lot, Patrick.