On Dec. 13, an election employee named Ruby Freeman took the stand in a Georgia courtroom and advised the story of how her world was turned the other way up by Rudy Giuliani. Three Decembers earlier, Giuliani shared a routine surveillance video of Ms. Freeman and her daughter, Shaye Moss, doing the routine but very important work of counting 2020 presidential ballots at State Farm Enviornment in Atlanta.
However Giuliani’s description of the video was something however routine. He falsely claimed that the footage was proof of vote fraud. In that second, every part modified for Freeman. As she stated in her testimony, “Giuliani simply messed me up, you understand.” That’s a well mannered manner of describing the horrors that adopted. She confronted an avalanche of threats, racist assaults and harassment at work and residential. She needed to depart her home — after which, after regulation enforcement officers discovered her title on a dying checklist, the home of the buddy she’d been staying with. Even now she’s afraid to stroll in public and not using a masks.
The aim of Freeman’s courtroom testimony was easy: to explain intimately how Giuliani’s lies had profoundly broken her life. And make no mistake, Giuliani lied. He admitted that his statements had been false again in July, and in August the courtroom entered a default judgment towards him, holding him accountable for these falsehoods. The one query left for the jury was the quantity of the damages. And Friday, the jury gave its reply: Giuliani now owes Freeman and Moss $148 million to compensate them for his merciless and apparent lies.
The decision is towards Giuliani alone. However make no mistake, MAGA was on trial within the courtroom — its strategies, its morality and the means it makes use of to flee the implications of its dreadful acts. That’s as a result of Rudy Giuliani isn’t really Rudy Giuliani any longer. In his lengthy descent from a post-9/11 American hero to a mocked, derided and embattled felony defendant (he has additionally been indicted in Fani Willis’s sprawling Georgia case), he grew to become one thing else fully. He grew to become a MAGA Man.
I’m reminded of Sigourney Weaver’s well-known line in “Ghostbusters”: “There isn’t any Dana, solely Zuul.” There isn’t any Giuliani now, solely Donald Trump.
There are various MAGA Males and MAGA Girls within the trendy G.O.P. To fulfill one is, in important respects, to fulfill all of them. The names roll off the tongue. Mark Meadows, Jim Jordan, Kari Lake, Roger Stone, Marjorie Taylor Greene, John Eastman — the checklist may go on and on. And whereas all of them have totally different tales earlier than Trump, they share variations of the identical story after Trump. Giuliani’s story, MAGA’s story, is theirs as nicely.
That’s what was most important about his trial. It wasn’t the harm award, as substantial because it was. It’s the story, the story that lays naked what a MAGA Man is.
The very first thing that you must find out about a MAGA Man like Giuliani is that he’s dishonest. Truthfulness is incompatible with Trumpism. Trump is a liar, and he calls for fealty to his lies. So Giuliani’s activity, as Trump’s lawyer, was to lie on his behalf, and lie he did. He even repeated his lies about Freeman and Moss — the identical lies to which he’d already confessed — exterior the courthouse throughout his trial.
A MAGA Man akin to Giuliani dietary supplements his lies with rage. To look at him pushing Trump’s election lies was to observe a person develop into unglued with anger. The craze merged with the lie. The craze helped make the lie stick. Why would a person like Giuliani, former prosecutor and hero mayor, be so indignant if he hadn’t found true injustice? MAGA Males and Girls are excellent at utilizing their credibility from the previous to cowl their lies within the current.
Amid the lies and rage, nonetheless, a MAGA Man like Giuliani additionally finds faith. However not in the best way you would possibly count on. No, MAGA Man is just not sorry for what he’s completed. As an alternative, he feels biblically persecuted. Freeman and Moss aren’t the actual victims; he’s. Furthermore, he additionally is aware of that the bottom is non secular and likes to listen to its politicians discuss God.
Giuliani discovered that lesson nicely. So in the course of the trial, he in contrast himself to Christians within the Colosseum, battling the lions just like the martyrs of previous. He’s not alone on this, after all. Trump shared a picture of Jesus sitting by his aspect as he stood trial. Stone obtained so non secular that he claimed to see supernatural sights, together with, he stated, a “demonic portal” that’s “swirling like a cauldron” in regards to the Biden White Home.
One of many persistent debates in American life facilities on how strictly we should always decide the sins of our nationwide previous. Have been these individuals who owned slaves or broke religion with Native People or handed the Chinese language Exclusion Act merely merchandise of their time? MAGA Males and MAGA Girls won’t have that excuse. They know there’s a totally different manner. Earlier than Trump, lots of them — no matter their flaws — lived very totally different lives. And few of them extra so than Giuliani.
His trial and verdict write one other web page within the quantity of reality that tells the actual story of MAGA America. Each voter ought to know precisely who Trump is and what his motion is like. They need to know what occurred to Ruby Freeman and Shaye Moss. We should always bear in mind their names. But when a MAGA Man remembers, he doesn’t care. Whoever he as soon as was is gone. He serves a brand new grasp now.
The Occasions is dedicated to publishing a range of letters to the editor. We’d like to listen to what you concentrate on this or any of our articles. Listed below are some ideas. And right here’s our e mail: letters@nytimes.com.
Comply with the New York Occasions Opinion part on Fb, Instagram, TikTok, X and Threads.
