Jost’s emailed reply was succinct:
He’s clearly probably the most impulsive and unpredictable U.S. president of our lifetimes, so I feel it’s inconceivable to say. However based mostly on the primary 100 days of this presidency, I’d say extraordinarily harmful to any and all democratic establishments and proponents.
Trump, Jost continued,
completely exemplifies all 9 traits of the authoritarian character syndrome:
(a) aggression towards those that deviate from established norms, (b) submission to idealized ethical authorities, (c) uncritical acceptance of typical values, (d) psychological rigidity and a proclivity to interact in stereotypical pondering, (e) a preoccupation with toughness and energy, (f) exaggerated sexual considerations, (g) a reluctance to interact in introspection, (h) an inclination to undertaking undesirable traits onto others, and (i) destructiveness and cynicism about human nature.
Steven Pinker, a psychologist at Harvard who has been on the forefront within the college’s confrontation with the Trump administration, identified that
To this point Trump has reacted with vengeance, threatening additional analysis cuts in addition to rescinding Harvard’s tax-free standing, in response to Harvard’s lawsuit, even after his administration admitted that the checklist of calls for had been despatched in error. That is certainly governance by revenge relatively than justice.
Bullies and road toughs, Pinker continued,
assume nicely of themselves not in proportion to their accomplishments however out of a congenital sense of entitlement. When actuality intrudes, because it inevitably will, they deal with the unhealthy information as a private affront, and its bearer, who’s endangering their fragile repute, as a malicious slanderer.
“And the trio of signs at narcissism’s core — grandiosity, want for admiration and lack of empathy — suits political tyrants to a T. It’s most blatant of their vainglorious monuments, hagiographic iconography, and obsequious mass rallies.
One of the crucial threatening traits of such leaders, Pinker wrote, is that “their lack of empathy imposes no brake on the punishment they mete out to actual or imagined opponents.”
There may be “an enormous distinction between traditional tyrants and Trump,” in response to Pinker:
It’s that his thirst for dominance and revenge usually loses out to his mercurial nature and quick consideration span. We noticed this within the border wall, tariffs, and different stop-and-start insurance policies.
He delights in chaos as a lot as in revenge. This implies he might lose curiosity in one in every of his vendettas and transfer on to the following one. Additionally, like road bullies, he thrives on bluff and bluster, and infrequently has a glass jaw when the goal is overwhelming. We noticed this in the truth that he did peacefully vacate the White Home in 2021 regardless of claiming that the election had been stolen.
There may be nonetheless a bigger query. If, within the face of adversity, Trump and his allies try to overturn democracy, what are their possibilities? I requested Herbert Kitschelt, a professor of worldwide relations at Duke and the 2025 recipient of the celebrated Johan Skytte Prize in political science, that query, and he supplied a nuanced reply by electronic mail: “No scientific, evidence-based investigation can presently present a factually grounded prognosis” on “whether or not and the way Trump and the Christian Evangelical-nationalist-Southern wing of the Republican Celebration may break the democratic structure of america,” he wrote.
As an alternative, Kitschelt argued, it’s doable to “define the forces that will impinge on whether or not this course of will happen or not.”
Kitschelt then specified the 4 elements working in favor of the institution of “an authoritarian coalition in america.”
-
1) “U.S. technological innovativeness and productiveness features — extra so than in different superior capitalist nations — have generated anxiousness amongst many occupational teams.”
-
2) “The U.S. has a weak welfare state — when it comes to pensions, well being care, unemployment insurance coverage, assist to households with kids, public schooling — when in comparison with nearly every other superior capitalist nation.”
-
3) “America is probably the most inegalitarian superior Western nation when it comes to revenue and wealth. That induces wealthy folks to advertise politicians who distract the economically worse-off from questions of financial distribution and focus their consideration on problems with political governance, tradition struggle, racial and ethnic hierarchies and nationalist claims to international supremacy.”
-
4) “In contrast to every other Western democracy, America has a deeply anti-democratic, illiberal, intolerant spiritual strand.”
Kitschelt went on to explain situations in america that “are opposed to the victory of an authoritarian coalition” and are, in distinction, favorable to democracy:
-
1) “America’s civil society: If it awakens from its present shock and slumber, indicators of that are already rising, it’s seemingly that it’s going to develop into a strong drive to uphold democracy.”
-
2) “Most significantly: American capitalism, massive segments of the U.S. enterprise class, whether or not in finance, IT and AI, U.S. producers in international manufacturing chains (autos, aerospace, pharma, and so forth.) and U.S. tradition industries are averse to a MAGA & Tea Celebration authoritarian coalition. Populism undercuts property rights and the rule of legislation, rendering it inconceivable to make rational, profit-generating, long-term enterprise investments.”
A extreme financial disaster, which Kitschelt believes is possible given present traits, would sharply undermine Republican prospects within the 2026 Congressional elections, which could immediate Trump and his allies to “notice that they can not win a free and truthful election, and really may face a defeat within the midterms extreme sufficient to precipitate the impeachment of each president and vice chairman.”
The query then turns into, in Kitschelt’s view,
Will evangelical-nationalist clero-fascism — with different MAGA and Tea Celebration currents in tow — be able to changing America into an electoral autocracy quicker than U.S. civil society and huge elements of the enterprise sector will have the ability to mobilize a protection of American democracy and to stiffen the backbone of the U.S. judiciary to protect American establishments?
The Instances is dedicated to publishing a variety of letters to the editor. We’d like to listen to what you concentrate on this or any of our articles. Listed below are some ideas. And right here’s our electronic mail: letters@nytimes.com.
Comply with the New York Instances Opinion part on Fb, Instagram, TikTok, Bluesky, WhatsApp and Threads.
