On a current journey to the United Arab Emirates, I felt as if I’d entered a fever dream of inexperienced exuberance. It was greater than two months earlier than COP28, the annual international local weather assembly, which is in progress in Dubai, however the nation was already awash in environmental hype. On the freeway, banners for an occasion hosted by the Abu Dhabi Nationwide Oil Firm, the fossil gas behemoth referred to as Adnoc, learn: “Decarbonizing. Quicker. Collectively.” A placard in my resort rest room requested me to preserve water by utilizing the two-tiered flush, though the flush had just one tier. A buddy’s utility invoice was labeled “inexperienced invoice” — though U.A.E. households have among the highest carbon footprints on the earth.
This tidal wave of excellent inexperienced vibes crashed over my social media feeds within the run-up to COP28. In mid-November, I noticed video of the half-mile-tall exterior of the Burj Khalifa — the world’s tallest constructing and an icon of glitzy, oil-financed consumerism — reworked right into a glittery temperature-gauge warning of impending international warming. “Motion builds hope,” the textual content proclaimed. “Hope conjures up motion. Motion delivers motion.”
Because the local weather disaster grows ever extra pressing, the U.A.E. is championing a dangerously seductive method to the issue: insisting that we will make investments and innovate our method out of environmental catastrophe, whereas altering as little as doable about our lifestyle. This philosophy might be discovered elsewhere however is most evident in Gulf petrostates just like the U.A.E. Tiny, wealthy and impressive, the nation is scrambling to lengthen its hydrocarbon wealth whereas rebranding itself as a pacesetter in sustainability.
This posture comes with some startling, and self-defeating, contradictions. The U.A.E. is restoring coastal mangroves ostensibly to attract down carbon from the ambiance, enhance biodiversity and defend its shoreline towards rising seas. However it is usually constructing synthetic islands that destroy marine ecosystems (together with coral reefs) whereas the coastal villas and excessive rises on them face a rising threat from flash floods. And in yet one more conflict of pursuits, the nation’s livability is determined by blasting air con and desalinating seawater that largely use fossil fuels: In 2022, renewable vitality offered solely 7 p.c of the U.A.E.’s energy.
The largest paradox of all is Sultan Al Jaber, the nation’s prime oil government and the president of this 12 months’s local weather summit. To his detractors, these two hats symbolize an irreconcilable battle of curiosity laid naked in remarks at a Nov. 21 occasion the place he claimed there was “no science” behind calls for for nations to conform to a fast phaseout of fossil fuels by the tip of the COP assembly on Dec. 12. Such a phaseout is inconceivable, he mentioned, “until you need to take the world again into caves.” Specialists promptly condemned the remarks as “verging on local weather denial,” citing a rising physique of proof that switching to scrub vitality may speed up financial progress. Mr. Al Jaber later mentioned the remarks had been “misinterpreted.”
Within the best-case situation, Mr. Al Jaber may assist persuade firms (together with oil firms) to cease damaging the local weather. In any case, he’s an uncommon oil government who additionally based and chairs Masdar, a state-owned renewables firm, and has pledged to spend $15 billion decarbonizing Adnoc’s operations by 2030, together with by carbon seize and electrification. Previously 12 months, the U.A.E. reportedly spent tens of billions of {dollars} on renewable vitality initiatives in nations from Turkey and Malaysia to Zambia and the USA. Such investments serve a number of functions: They diversify the U.A.E.’s income streams, burnish Abu Dhabi’s inexperienced credentials and cement political and financial relationships globally. At house, the U.A.E. goals to get 30 p.c of its vitality from renewable and nuclear energy by 2030.
However like the whole lot with the U.A.E., the story grows muddier when you think about that Adnoc can be investing $150 billion to extend its oil manufacturing capability and is securing huge swaths of Africa to pursue doubtful carbon-offsetting initiatives.
Neighboring Saudi Arabia is grappling with all the identical contradictions, supersized. The globe’s second-biggest oil producer, Saudi Arabia has greater than triple the U.A.E.’s inhabitants, simply over half its per capita earnings and most of the similar environmental pressures. It, too, has massive plans to diversify its economic system, together with by tourism, actual property and sustainable vitality. Simply take a look at Neom, a futuristic metropolis underneath building within the Saudi desert underwritten by $500 billion in oil wealth that goals to perform as a hub for local weather tech like inexperienced hydrogen, desert agriculture and solar-powered desalination.
It stays to be seen whether or not these guarantees will bear fruit. There’s loads of trigger for skepticism: Building on Neom has been delayed for years, not least by heavy turnover amongst expatriate employees members complaining of poisonous work situations. And on the similar time, the dominion is difficult at work ensuring it will possibly maintain promoting large portions of oil for many years to come back: An undercover investigation by the Centre for Local weather Reporting not too long ago discovered that Saudi Arabia goals to lock-in oil and gasoline dependency in poor nations — together with by creating low cost, petrol- or diesel-powered autos to be marketed throughout Asia and Africa.
The U.A.E. and Saudi Arabia is perhaps essentially the most flamboyant proponents of the idea {that a} nation is usually a chief on local weather whereas refusing to compromise on fossil fuels. However they’re removed from alone. America, in some ways, is a mirror picture. We’re the one nation pumping extra oil than Saudi Arabia, and manufacturing is increasing quick: A president who promised “no new drilling” on the marketing campaign path in 2020 has accepted a lot new drilling that some consultants warn it’s going to cancel out the emissions reductions from the tons of of billions of {dollars} his administration has funneled into clear infrastructure funding.
This should be forcing the American policymakers working towards international local weather options at COP28 to confront a urgent query: How can we push petrostates to maneuver quicker on decarbonization once we’re transferring too slowly ourselves? Ideally, we might lead by instance: taming our personal dependancy to fossil fuels earlier than anticipating others to do the identical.
Failing that, Washington can at the least work with states just like the U.AE., Saudi Arabia and Qatar to maneuver past the hype and the glitz. That might imply joint investments on international issues that really matter — resembling decarbonizing heavy business and air journey, quickly scaling up sustainable tech for desalination and air con, and investing extra in inexperienced vitality and catastrophe resilience in poor nations.
However it additionally means calling out the extra cynical excesses of governments like Mr. Al Jaber’s. Saudi Arabia can’t declare to champion sustainability within the creating world whereas scheming to get African nations hooked on oil. And the U.A.E. can’t blithely downplay local weather science days earlier than internet hosting a pivotal convention from which all of us want actual solutions.
Alex Simon is a co-founder of Synaps, a Beirut-based analysis heart. He leads a workforce finding out environmental adaptation throughout the Center East and North Africa.
Supply photos by Gary Yeowell, Floortje, Hanna Zherdieva, Peter Dazeley, Jacobs Inventory Pictures Ltd, and Yulia Naumenko/Getty Photos
The Instances is dedicated to publishing a range of letters to the editor. We’d like to listen to what you consider this or any of our articles. Listed here are some suggestions. And right here’s our e-mail: letters@nytimes.com.
Observe the New York Instances Opinion part on Fb, Instagram, TikTok, X and Threads.
