When President Trump positioned new tariffs on China this month, he doubled down on one in all his high calls for on Beijing: to rein within the chemical firms fueling the illicit manufacturing and trafficking of fentanyl into the US. Mr. Trump has lengthy argued that China is a big contributor to overdoses which have killed extra than 400,000 Individuals over the past decade, and he’s proper. For years, Chinese language firms have equipped the overwhelming majority of the deadly chemical substances that drug cartels around the globe use to supply the fentanyl flooding American streets.
However beginning a commerce warfare isn’t an answer to this downside — and will make it worse. Tariffs alone won’t push China’s authorities to assist scale back drug overdose deaths in the US. The truth is, with Beijing already imposing retaliatory tariffs and proclaiming that it’s “able to struggle until the top,” Trump’s blunt-force ways may drive China to cooperate much less on fentanyl, no more. With the stakes as excessive as they’re, American communities can’t afford a miscalculation.
Beginning in 2016, overdose deaths from artificial opioids — primarily fentanyl — started skyrocketing throughout the US. When Joe Biden took workplace in early 2021, the variety of such deaths had elevated 30 p.c from the earlier 12 months, with tens of hundreds of Individuals killed. In February 2024, my household joined the a whole lot of hundreds of American households who’ve misplaced a beloved one to this epidemic when a relative died from a fentanyl overdose. This private tragedy occurred simply two weeks after I joined the State Division to assist lead the Biden administration’s effort to handle world fentanyl trafficking.
With heightened readability about fentanyl’s devastating influence, I spent the previous 12 months serving to lead the U.S. diplomatic offensive to curtail Chinese language firms’ position as the worldwide suppliers of the precursor chemical substances which might be used to make unlawful fentanyl. We used each lever of American energy — from legislation enforcement to sanctions to diplomacy — to pursue progress on curbing fentanyl precursors with China’s authorities. And whereas it wasn’t good, it was working.
In 2021, President Biden issued an govt order imposing sanctions on people and firms engaged within the illicit opioid commerce. His Treasury Division put sanctions on greater than 300 people and entities, freezing total networks of fentanyl suppliers and traffickers out of the worldwide monetary system. In 2023 and 2024, Mr. Biden recognized China as a significant illicit drug-producing nation for its position within the artificial opioid commerce, a blow to the popularity of China’s chemical business.
Concurrently, the Biden administration pushed U.S. legislation enforcement companies to conduct aggressive investigations and construct indictments towards dozens of Chinese language residents and firms that had been trafficking fentanyl precursor chemical substances into the US. The Division of Justice labored intently with international governments from Fiji to Morocco to arrest Chinese language traffickers and extradite them to the US for prosecution. The primary convictions had been handed down simply final month.
The Biden administration matched these accountability measures with diplomatic motion. In July 2023, Secretary of State Antony Blinken began the World Coalition to Deal with Artificial Drug Threats, rallying greater than 160 international locations — not together with China — to step up efforts to fight the artificial drug commerce, successfully aligning the world with Washington’s agenda, not Beijing’s.
This initiative set the stage for President Biden to safe a private dedication from President Xi Jinping to restart counternarcotics cooperation in November 2023 — a necessary step in China’s hierarchical, authoritarian political system, the place selections about how and when to cooperate with the US are managed on the very high. In parallel, China’s authorities issued a public discover to its chemical business that detailed prison punishments for promoting precursor chemical substances that might be used to supply illicit fentanyl and different narcotics.
All through 2024, between a number of cabinet-level conferences and repeated rounds of technical talks, the Biden administration continued to push China to impose new restrictions on the sale of deadly chemical substances and transfer towards prison traffickers. Throughout that point, Beijing positioned new prohibitions on the sale of greater than 50 narcotics and deadly chemical substances, and joined the US in voting for brand spanking new worldwide rules on fentanyl precursor chemical substances on the United Nations.
The USA pressed China to take the primary joint legislation enforcement motion towards drug trafficking in a number of years, together with the arrest of a key Chinese language trafficker. And China’s authorities started much-needed, albeit piecemeal, efforts to take down the net marketplaces that promote deadly chemical substances to worldwide drug trafficking syndicates.
Can China’s authorities do extra? Completely. It could actually get severe about curbing the underground banking and monetary crimes that facilitate gross sales of precursor chemical substances. However in combining diplomacy with concrete actions, the Biden administration set the agenda for the way the 2 international locations can crack down on illicit fentanyl manufacturing.
And we made progress. Worldwide fentanyl provide chains confirmed indicators of disruption, forcing traffickers to alter sources and ways. Along with different diplomatic initiatives and an expansive public well being marketing campaign, the variety of deadly fentanyl overdoses in the US has dropped. Within the 12 months ending September 2024, overdose deaths had been down an estimated 24 p.c from the 12 months prior. 1000’s of American lives have been saved.
The opioid overdose epidemic is way from over. President Trump now has a possibility to attempt to end the job. However to try this, he might want to safe a dedication from Mr. Xi to proceed the work that’s already underway. Mr. Trump can push China to implement present restrictions on its chemical business extra aggressively. He can insist that China absolutely dismantle the net marketplaces promoting fentanyl precursor chemical substances to transnational prison organizations. And he can name for China to put new restrictions on its transport business, in order that deadly chemical substances by no means go away its shores.
None of this may occur with tariffs alone. Pressuring the Chinese language authorities is a vital a part of U.S. diplomacy, and tariffs, if deployed skillfully, can present leverage over Beijing because it makes an attempt to handle its struggling economic system. However ramping up strain with out a clear diplomatic or authorized street map might reverse current good points. Chinese language officers have already signaled that the brand new U.S. tariffs “will deal a heavy blow to counternarcotics dialogue and cooperation.”
To make additional progress, Mr. Trump must direct his cupboard to get to work and have interaction within the painstaking diplomacy that can be mandatory to save lots of extra U.S. lives. No matter political affiliation, all Individuals ought to hope he succeeds.
Brandon P. Yoder, a visiting fellow on the Wilson Middle, was a deputy assistant secretary for worldwide narcotics and legislation enforcement affairs within the Biden administration and a Democratic employees member for the Senate Overseas Relations Committee.
The Instances is dedicated to publishing a range of letters to the editor. We’d like to listen to what you consider this or any of our articles. Listed below are some ideas. And right here’s our electronic mail: letters@nytimes.com.
Observe the New York Instances Opinion part on Fb, Instagram, TikTok, Bluesky, WhatsApp and Threads.
